As a reader, journaler, and handwriting enthusiast, I’ve thought about starting a reading or book journal more times than I can count. Every now and then, I’ll walk into a bookstore or stationery shop here in Helsinki and spot a gorgeous one with pretty cover, cute template, maybe even a built-in bookmark. And for a second, I’m tempted.

But then I flip through the pages… and I never quite click with it. None of the layouts or prompts feel like me. Functionally speaking, I’d still rather reach for my trusty commonplace notebook.

So here’s why a reading journal doesn’t suit me. At least, not yet.

The Templates Feel Too Limiting

Most reading journals come with fixed templates: one or two pages per book, with tidy boxes for “favorite quotes,” “summary,” or “rating.” It’s neat, sure, but it also feels a little boxed in.

Every book I read has its own personality. Some are full of memorable lines that I want to copy word for word, while others make me scribble thoughts in the margins or connect ideas to my own experiences. Sometimes I want to highlight the flow of the story or even map out the plot.

And since I read both nonfiction and fiction, the way I take notes can change completely from one book to another. But reading journals often assume one-size-fits-all: one page per book, one format, one flow. And that just doesn’t work for me.

I like the freedom to write as much (or as little) as I want. If a book has ten quotes that move me, I want space for all ten, not a single “favorite quote” box.

My Commonplace Book Just Makes More Sense

That’s where my commonplace book comes in. It’s my no-rules, write-whatever-I-want space. I write down anything that stands out: a line that resonates, a clever metaphor, or even my own thoughts in response. There’s no structure, no limits, and that’s exactly how I like it.

I even have a simple color system: blue ink for direct quotes from the book, and another color for my reflections or thoughts. It’s not fancy, but it makes flipping back through my notes so much easier. When I’m looking for a particular line or idea, I can spot it at a glance.

There’s also something really satisfying about how organic it feels.

---

So yes, I still admire those beautifully designed reading journals every time I see them on a shelf and I understand some people find this really helpful for their reading experience. Maybe one day I’ll find one that truly fits my way of reading. But for now, my commonplace book gives me everything I need: space, freedom, and a place where my reading and thoughts can grow side by side.